Sir Arthur Conan Doyle heard about the fairy pictures and managed to borrow some copies. He created quite a stir with his articles on fairies and lectures on Spiritualism. People had many things to say about the matter:
"On the evidence I have no hesitation in saying that these photographs could have been 'faked'. I criticize the attitude of those who declared there is something supernatural in the circumstances attending to the taking of these pictures because, as a medical man, I believe that the inculcation of such absurd ideas into the minds of children will result in later life in manifestations and nervous disorder and mental disturbances…" (Major Hall-Edward, a radium expert)
"For the true explanation of these fairy photographs what is wanted is not a knowledge of occult phenomena but a knowledge of children." (Truth Newspaper)
"The day we kill our Santa Claus with our statistics we shall have plunged a glorious world into deepest darkness". (South Wales Argus)
"It seems at this point that we must either believe in the almost incredible mystery of the fairy or in the almost incredible wonders of faked photographs." (City News)
"I went off, too, to Cottingley again, taking the two cameras and plates from London, and met the family and explained to the two girls the simple working of the cameras, giving one each to keep. The cameras were loaded, and my final advice was that they need go up to the glen only on fine days as they had been accustomed to do before and tice the fairies, as they called their way of attracting them, and see what they could get. I suggested only the most obvious and easy precautions about lighting and distance, for I knew it was essential they should feel free and unhampered and have no burden of responsibility. If nothing came of it all, I told them, they were not to mind a bit."
From: Polly Wright (Elsie's mother)
To: Edward Gardner
Date: August 19, 1920 (Thursday)
"The morning was dull and misty so they did not take any photos until after dinner when the mist had cleared away and it was sunny. I went to my sister's for tea and left them to it. When I got back they had only managed two with fairies, I was disappointed."
Two days later...
"They went up again on Saturday afternoon and took several photos but there was only one with anything on and it's a queer one, we can't make it out. Elsie put the plates in this time and Arthur developed them next day. P.S. She did not take one flying after all."
The girls managed to take three more pictures that were sent to Conan Doyle while he was on his Australian lecture tour. He wrote:
"My heart was gladdened when out here in far Australia I had your note and the three wonderful pictures which are confirmatory of our published results. When our fairies are admitted other psychic phenomena will find a more ready acceptance … we have had continued messages at seances for some time that a visible sign was coming through...."
Austin Mitchell's Interview with Elsie and Francis:
Mitchell: A rational person doesn't see fairies. If people say they see fairies, then one's bound to be critical.
Mitchell: Now, if you say you saw them, at the time the photograph was taken, that means that if there's a confidence trick, then you're both part of it.
Frances: Yes–that's fair enough–yes.
Mitchell: So are you?
Frances: Of course not.
Mitchell: Did you, in any way, fabricate those photographs?
Frances: Of course not. You tell us how she could do it, remember she was 16 and I was 10. So, then, as a child of 10, can you go through life and keep a secret?
But in 1981, both cousins said that the photos were fake and that they had held up cut-outs with hatpins. Frances insisted until her death (July 1986) that the 5th photo was genuine, and that they had really seen fairies.
1982 Interview on Arthur C. Clarke's World of Strange Powers:
Elsie: "Two village kids and a brilliant man like Conan Doyle, well, we could only keep quiet."
Frances: "I never even thought of it as being a fraud — it was just Elsie and I having a bit of fun and I can't understand to this day why they were taken in — they wanted to be taken in."